The Importance of Conversational Frames
|By Stephan Lewandowsky
Professor, School of Experimental Psychology and Cabot Institute, University of Bristol
Posted on 28 April 2011
Filed under Culture
Societies rely on tacit “frames” to conduct and understand conversations. One popular frame in Western democracies is the notion of “balance”—the idea that all sides of an issue deserve to be heard and that solutions can be found by balancing their demands and needs. This idea entails the assumption that all sides have a roughly symmetrical entitlement to be heard.
There is much merit to this notion. In Australian politics, the introduction of the GST (a VAT equivalent) was a case in point. After much parliamentary and public debate, a compromise was found by which food remained exempt from the GST—balancing the original plan of omnibus taxation with the need to control the basic costs of living. Similar examples abound in most Western democracies.
Resistance to such balance may deservedly earn the label “extremist,” although this label is applicable only when the media landscape in which a debate takes place is not systematically distorted.
Setting aside such possible distortions for now, “balance” is only one of several conversational frames in society. In some situations the idea of a symmetric entitlement of opinions is ludicrous, and an alternative frame is used that gives strong preference to one side over the other—for good reason: Few would propose that the needs and opinions of law enforcement ought to be “balanced” with those of organized crime. Tax revenues are legitimately reserved for the police and judiciary, and there is no “balancing” public expenditure for crime lords, Godfathers, and drug barons.
One would rarely be labelled “extremist” when invoking the Law in preference to protection rackets, bribery, or the armed militias of drug barons.
Tragedy strikes when a society confuses the applicability of those two very different frames.
Imagine what would happen to a country when the head of its national broadcaster accused the police and courts of “group think” and suggested that the Consigliere’s opinions should be given more weight by the judiciary. Imagine a country in which the leader of a major party referred to the Law as “crap” and met with one of the Godfathers for an extended private chat. Imagine a country in which the rule of law has been replaced with the rule of who can shout the loudest in the media.
Those are not just scary thoughts. They represent the frightening reality that has engulfed not just Australia but also—and perhaps even more so—the United States. Segments of those societies and the media have lost their grip on which conversational frame applies to the greatest scientific and ethical problems humanity has ever faced—climate change and how to deal with it by decarbonizing our economies.
The only “balance” that applies to climate science is that of evidence—and not of opinion or interests. In the same way that the verdicts of the courts should trump the protestations of organized crime, so the peer-reviewed literature must always trump internet cacophony or the opinions of ideological think tanks.
Tragically, however, the media now often “balance” science with noise that could be debunked in a few mouse clicks. In Australia, a Catholic Cardinal recently provided a perfect if stunning illustration of such ill-conceived “balance” when he gave Dr. Ayers, the Head of the Bureau of Meteorology, a public lesson—not in seeking prayer or avoiding divorce but in how to conduct science. Thumping a particularly egregious piece of fiction written by an individual with no relevant peer-reviewed publications but several directorships of mining corporations, the Cardinal called Dr. Ayers’s testimony to the Australian Senate … “unscientific.” Unscientific, because Dr. Ayers relied on the peer-reviewed literature in coming to his judgment that the Earth is warming owing to human CO2 emissions.
On the positive side, this incident underscores that in modern Catholicism Cardinals have latitude to ignore the Holy See’s opinions. On the more negative side, the largely uncritical and detached stance of the national media reveals that they have abandoned the distinction between evidence and noise, between peer-review and internet memes, between science and anti-scientific ideology.
Lest one think that the Cardinal’s episode is an isolated incident, recent research at the University of Queensland found that among Australian politicians, the percentage whose views on climate are influenced by scientists—as opposed to some other source, perhaps cat palmistry—ranges from 44% to 98% across the different parties. The extremist party that in its majority rejects science is on the conservative side of politics (called the Liberal Party), whereas the party that nearly exclusively relies on peer-reviewed science is the Greens—yet, the latter are readily labelled “extremist” by the media whereas the former are considered mainstream and “serious.”
This situation brings into focus several important questions: Does it matter? And how do we move on from here?
There are some good arguments that this faux “balance” and misrepresentation of science ought to be set aside—after all, the vast majority of Australians are convinced that climate change is happening and most also admit that humans are largely responsible (even if only indirectly; Leviston & Walker, 2010). In light of peak oil and other good reasons to abandon fossil fuels, perhaps we should just move on and transition to renewable forms of energy—which Australians seem to support by an overwhelming margin—and ignore the noise and inaccuracies in the media?
Two considerations speak against this option. First, there is some evidence that correct understanding of the causes of global warming is associated with people’s intentions to change relevant behaviours. For example, Bord et al. (2000) showed in a survey of more than 1000 Americans that “knowing what causes climate change, and what does not, is the most powerful predictor of both stated intentions to take voluntary actions and to vote on hypothetical referenda to enact new government policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions” (p. 205). Although this association may be moderated by other variables, such as political orientation (Malka et al., 2009), existing results leave little doubt that public misrepresentations of science are likely to have consequences, because public confusion about the science is one impediment to acting on climate change.
The second consideration may sound quaint in contemporary society but nonetheless cannot be ignored: It is simply a moral issue whether a society tolerates and acquiesces to systematic public misrepresentations and distortions of science and scientists. There is ample evidence for an association between public misperceptions of climate science and people’s preferred news outlets (Ramsay et al., 2010); people who preferentially get their news from Fox are most likely to be incorrectly informed about the state of climate science and in particular the consensus among climate scientists. This is not surprising in light of the recent revelation that casting doubt on climate data is a matter of editorial policy within this particular ”news” outlet.
So how do we move forward? Cognitive science has much to offer in this regard; from reframing to social norming and research on reasoning and ideology, we know much about barriers to public comprehension and action. That knowledge will be most helpful in assisting policy makers maximize the effectiveness of climate action.
But throughout, however the public debate may unfold, we must recognize that the only balance that counts in science is that of evidence. It appears inadvisable to lose track of that fact, even if segments of the media and society have slid into a bizarre corner from which evidence and reality appear “extremist” or “fundamentalist.”
(A shorter version of this article first appeared on The Conversation on 28 April 2011. It has been extended and updated for posting here)
Bord, R. J.; O'Connor, R. E. & Fisher, A. (2000). In what sense does the public need to understand global climate change? Public Understanding of Science, 9, 205-218.
Leviston, Z. & Walker, I. A. (2010). Baseline survey of Australian attitudes to climate change: Preliminary report. CSIRO (Behavioural Sciences Research Group).
Malka, A.; Krosnick, J. A. & Langer, G. (2009). The Association of Knowledge with Concern About Global Warming: Trusted Information Sources Shape Public Thinking
Risk Analysis, 29, 633-647.
Ramsay, C.; Kull, S.; Lewis, E. & Subias, S. (2010). Misinformation and the 2010 election: A study of the US electorate. Program on International Policy Attitudes, University of Maryland.
Comments 1 to 43:
Unfortunately, as long as the majority of Australians get their news from the channel 7/9/10 news and the tabloids-in-disguise papers, not much will change. In the public health area, I think a lot of people gain an understanding of health issues from popular "media doctors" like Andrew Rochford on the "7pm project" -- so easy access to scientific information communicated in everyday language by someone who is believable and likeable in a programme people are watching anyway. So finding ways to get science (and I basically mean any science, not just climate science) into mainstream media in an undistorted fashion will be a big but worthwile challenge.
I like this post,And I guess that they having fun to read this post,they shall take a good site to make a information,thanks for sharing it to me.
how to get followers
thanks for the tips and information..i really appreciate it..
kosten hochzeit dj
These are some great tools that i definitely use for SEO work. This is a great list to use in the future..
wealthy affiliate review
This one is good. keep up the good work!..
I really thank you for the valuable info on this great subject and look forward to more great posts. Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty article with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great article. Good luck to the author! All the best!
Venus Factor Review
Interesting topic for a blog. I have been searching the Internet for fun and came upon your website. Fabulous post. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites. I'll be sure to check back again real soon.
iherb coupon code
Im no expert, but I believe you just made an excellent point. You certainly fully understand what youre speaking about, and I can truly get behind that.
This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it
increase youtube views free
This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post.
electrical contractors Birmingham
i really like this article please keep it up.
Social Video Consultant Review
I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.
dental implants cost per tooth
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.
Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here...
amazing selling machine review
I really impressed after read this because of some quality work and informative thoughts . I just wanna say thanks for the writer and wish you all the best for coming!.
Build My List 2.0 review
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article.
This article is an appealing wealth of informative data that is interesting and well-written. I commend your hard work on this and thank you for this information. You’ve got what it takes to get attention.
The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing...
ecom premier academy bonus
I have read your blog it is very helpful for me. I want to say thanks to you. I have bookmark your site for future updates.
The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
good morning sms
I have been looking at a couple of your stories and i can state really well done. I will bookmark your website future technology
This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives indepth information. Thanks for this nice article. how to buy followers on instagram for free buy likes cheap
Fabulous online journal you have here. You'll find me taking a gander at your stuff regularly. Spared! transfert cassettes
All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts.Thanks http://www.enziweb.com
Hi there everyone, it’s my first pay a visit at this website, I am taking a look ahead to your next submit, I will attempt to get the cling of it! http://khelomcx.com/
Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. aftermarket car parts
I really thank you for the valuable info on this great subject and look forward to more great posts. Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty article with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great article. Good luck to the author! All the best! varicose vein center
Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks
Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks vintage shopping online
Great article ! Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.
the baby swing reviews
Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards, ds-indy.com/
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post. dofollow backlink service …………… Blog Comments
Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. mihran kalaydjian
Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Thank you for sharing great information to us. Wireless Whiskers
Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!!!!! dtv-installations.com
Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. internet marketing
I just couldn't leave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts. CenturyLink Login
I just couldn't leave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts. Webkinz Login
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine. best fiverr gigs for seo …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Thank you very much for the sharing! COOL.. best fiverr gigs for seo …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here... best fiverr seo gigs …………… Link Building
Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here. best fiverr seo gigs …………… Link Building
Thank you very much for keep this information. best fiverr seo gigs …………… Link Building
thanks this is good blog. best fiverr seo gigs …………… Link Building
Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! best fiverr seo gigs …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Thank you very much for this useful article. I like it. best link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. best link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
I read that Post and got it fine and informative. best link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Please share more like that. best link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
New web site is looking good. Thanks for the great effort. best link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. best quality link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Thank you for the update, very nice site.. best quality link building service …………… Buy High PR BackLinks
Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! best quality link building service …………… Do You Want BackLinks? Contact Me
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often. best quality link building service …………… Do You Want BackLinks? Contact Me
This blog is so nice to me. I will keep on coming here again and again. Visit my link as well.. best quality link building service …………… Do You Want BackLinks? Contact Me
Great post, and great website. Thanks for the information! http://rhythmandpower.com
Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here. http://videogamesnews.co/
I love this blog!! The flash up the top is awesome!! How much dry food to feed a cat
Post a Comment
You need to be logged in to post a comment. Login via the left margin or register a new account.